Your Pizza Passport to the Best Slices in New York City

If you’ve been here awhile then you know New York City is my hometown and one of our favorite cities. It has incredible nightlife, iconic landmarks, and delicious food. But no other food takes the spotlight like the New York Style Pizza. As a professional pizza expert (self-proclaimed) we decided to dedicate all future NYC trips to crossing off a least a few new spots from our Pizza Passport. Here’s some of the best pizza You need to try while visiting New York City!


Ultimate Eclectic NYC Pizza List:

  • Una Pizza Napoletana
  • Tottono’s
  • Lombardi’s
  • Scarr’s Pizza
  • Grimaldi’s
  • Juliana’s
  • Joe & Pat’s
  • Di Fara Pizza
  • John’s of Bleecker Street
  • Joe’s Pizza
  • Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop
  • Prince Street Pizza
  • Roberta’s
  • Upside Pizza
  • Artichoke Basilleโ€™s Pizza
  • L’Industrie Pizzeria

Other Top Pizza’s in the USA

We may be a purist when it comes to New York’s flavorful collections of pizza, but that doesn’t mean we can’t acknowledge some other various styles we’ve tasted across the country (Obviously we are purposefully leaving out Italy since it’s on a whole other level). Here more amazing pies to try while traveling across the country!

  • Giordano’s – Deep Dish Style (Chicago)
  • Lou Malnatiโ€™s – Deep Dish Style (Chicago)
  • Pequodโ€™s – Deep Dish Style (Chicago)
  • Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana – New Haven Style (Connecticut)
  • Buddy’s Pizza – Detroit Style (Michigan)
  • Imo’s Pizza – St. Louis Style (St. Louis Missouri)
  • Pizzeria Bianco – Artisanal Wood-fired style (Phoenix Arizona)

Other than NYC Pizza:

It’s almost impossible to survive on a diet of only pizza, especially when there are so many other fantastic foods to try in New York City! Just incase you need to mix things up, we’ve included a variety of authentic top tier cuisine to try while visiting the city.

  • Soup Dumplings – Joeโ€™s Shanghai
  • Bagels – Ess-a-Bagel
  • Rainbow Bagels – Liberty Bagels Midtown
  • Gyros – The Halal Guys
  • Chopped Cheese or bacon egg and cheese from a bodega
  • Dim Sum in China Town
  • Pastrami on Rye – Katz delicatessen
  • Banana pudding – Magnolia Bakeryโ€™s
  • Tacos – Los Tacos No. 1
  • NY Style Hot Dog at Grayโ€™s Papaya or Nathan’s
  • Cookies – Levain Bakery
  • Oysters – Grand Central Oyster Bar
  • Ramen – Momofukuโ€™s Noddle Bar
  • Cannoli – Ferrara

More Non-Pizza Things to do in NYC

Between chowing down on that delicious NYC pizza, walking it off at New York’s famous landmarks is a must. Of course there is an endless amount of experiences to enjoy in the city, as is evident in our Top 100 best things to do in New York City Travel blog suggests. But there’s always new and exciting events popping up in the city! Here’s a few newer activities on our bucket list:

  • The MET Cloisters
  • Catacombs in Basillica of St. Patrickโ€™s Old Cathedral
  • Coney Island
  • Brooklyn Flea  Sat 10am – 5pm
  • Smorgasburg  Sat 11am – 6pm
  • Dekalb Market
  • Mercer Labs Museum of Art and Technology
  • Tenement Museum  10am – 6pm
  • Prospect Park
  • American Museum of Natural History
  • Times Square Auditory Art – Broadway Pedestrian Plaza between 45th and 46th Streets (between Broadway and Seventh Avenue)
  • The Bean Sculpture in Tribecca
  • Games at Cellar Dog (Fat Cat)
  • The Polonksky exhibition of NY public libraryโ€™s treasure
  • Bath house Flatiron 
  • Squid Game experience 

New York is an ever-evolving landscape for travelers, but these are a few new experiences to add to the continuously growing NYC Bucket List. The NYC Pizza game is top tier, and we’ll do our best to try them all so we can guide you to pizza perfection. Stay tuned as we’ll be periodically updating the list! Thanks for reading and keep leveling up!


Check out how we spent a summer in Nuevayol sightseeing medieval castles and eating pizza!

Check out our review of the world’s #1 ranked best pizza!

Check out our Digital Travel Guide: How to Save Money & Travel More! For our best tips on booking cheap flights, hotels, and the best travel hacks for saving money on your trips!

How to Save Money & Travel More! Eclectic Travel Guide